You’re protected at the car dealership now. Wrong. Dead wrong.
The Federal Trade Commission’s Combating Auto Retail Scams Rule — the CARS Rule — was supposed to ban hidden fees, stop fake add-ons, and require dealers to disclose the actual price of a vehicle upfront. The Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals vacated it. Entirely. That protection you thought was coming? It’s gone.
—
The CARS Rule Didn’t Die Because Dealers Were Right
The most dangerous myth floating around is that the Fifth Circuit threw out the CARS Rule because the FTC overstepped its authority or because the rule was legally flawed. That’s not what happened. The court vacated the rule on procedural grounds — specifically, the FTC failed to follow its own required rulemaking process before finalizing the regulation.
The court didn’t rule that junk fees at dealerships are acceptable. It didn’t say dealer deception is legal. It said the FTC skipped steps it was required to take, and that’s enough to kill the rule.
That distinction matters enormously for you. The underlying consumer harms the rule targeted — undisclosed add-ons, bait-and-switch pricing, financing traps — are still happening every day.
—
Dealers Aren’t Charging “Small” Fees — The Numbers Are Brutal
The second myth is that dealer add-on fees are minor annoyances, not real financial damage. Pull up the data.
According to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, undisclosed or poorly disclosed add-on products — things like paint protection, GAP insurance, and extended warranties bundled without consent — cost American car buyers an estimated $1,000 to $3,700 per transaction on average, often financed at the vehicle’s loan rate over five or six years. That’s not a nuisance. That’s a second credit card.
“I didn’t even know I had a $2,400 paint sealant on my loan until I got home and read the paperwork,” said Marcus T., a Chicago buyer who purchased a used SUV in early 2025. “By then I’d already signed.”
Without the CARS Rule in force, dealers have no federal obligation to itemize these products before you sign. State laws vary wildly. Some states offer real protection. Many offer almost none.
—
State Laws Help — But Only If You’re in the Right State
Here’s where it gets complicated, and this myth is partially true. Some consumer advocates are telling buyers that state attorney general offices and existing FTC Section 5 authority still protect them. They’re not wrong. But the caveat is critical.
Section 5 of the FTC Act prohibits unfair or deceptive practices, and the FTC can still pursue individual enforcement actions against the worst offenders. Several states — California, New York, Illinois — have their own auto dealer disclosure laws with real teeth. If you live there, you have meaningful backup.
If you live in Texas, Georgia, or roughly 30 other states with weaker dealer regulations, you’re negotiating in a room with no referee. The CARS Rule would have applied nationally and uniformly. State patchwork doesn’t do that.
—
How to Protect Your Wallet Before the FTC Tries Again
The FTC hasn’t abandoned the CARS Rule. Consumer advocates expect a revised rulemaking attempt, but that process takes years — potentially three to five — and faces a hostile regulatory environment in 2026. You can’t wait for Washington.
Here’s what you can actually do right now, before you walk onto any lot.
Ask for the out-the-door price in writing before any test drive, before any financing discussion, and before you provide your social security number for a credit check. That number must include every fee, every add-on, every dealer charge. If they won’t give it to you, walk.
Bring an OBD2 scanner for used vehicles — it reads the car’s diagnostic history directly and tells you what the dealer’s inspection may not. It’s a $30 tool that’s saved buyers thousands. A dash cam installed from day one also documents delivery condition if a dealer later disputes damage claims.
Reject every add-on product at signing. Every single one. If you want GAP insurance — and sometimes you do need it — buy it from your own insurance provider at a fraction of the dealer’s price.
The CARS Rule would have done some of this work automatically. It doesn’t exist anymore. So you have to do it manually, transaction by transaction, and you have to do it before you sign anything.
Before your next car purchase, pull your state’s auto dealer consumer complaint records from your state attorney general’s website — search the specific dealership name and read what other buyers reported.
